The case of fords pinto has been called a manifestation of broad legal, socialstructural, and ideological changes leading to an increasing intolerance of white collar crime. During the 1970s there were many documented cases of ford pintos bursting into flames as a result of rearend collisions. Ford pinto full details and analysis report with references 1. When ford began development of the pinto in 1968, the company hoped that the cars smaller size and price tag would help it compete with japanese and. Hoffmans treatment of the case raises some of the questions about the difficulty of determining relevant standards that will be raised later in this paper. Ford pinto full details and analysis report with references. The cases involving the explosion of ford pinto s due to a defective fuel system design led to the debate of many issues, most centering around the use by ford of a costbenefit analysis and the ethics surrounding its decision not to upgrade the fuel system based on this analysis. There is one and only one social responsibility of business to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition without. In fact, few imports could match their domestic counterparts, the. Ford pinto case ethical issues on august 10, 1978 three young girls died in a 1973 ford pinto after being stuck from the rear by a driver in a van. Center for the study of ethics in the professions, illinois institute of technology. Taylor gray brenda greenwell christopher macintyre leanne marks university of phoenix mgt 216 march 17, 2010 table of contents introduction 3 recommended solutions and supporting information to the ford pinto case 3 traffic safety and accident data 4 ethical opinion 5 influences from external social pressures 5 case examined with the period eye 6. Can be used as part of a series, managing product safety, the opportunity to compare and contrast the social response strategies employed by companies involved in a catastrophic product safety controversy as intended to be used. The model t, in particular, was the one turning point that put ford on the map.
So, milton friedman gives us what has become the dominant view of business social responsibility. The ford pinto case businessmarketing bibliographies. An alternative account of the ford pinto case pdh online. Ford pinto caseevents in the 1970s related to the ford pinto automobile illustrate some of the ethical issues related to technology and safety. The ford pinto was completely engulfed in flames and the accident resulted in the death of the three young girls. In designing its 1971 pinto, the ford motor company decided to place the gas tank behind the rear axle. These are the sources and citations used to research the ford pinto case. The purpose of this paper is to look at three different types of ethical theories and they are applicable to ford pinto case. Iacocca viewed people as objects to be manipulated and harmed in order to achieve his ultimate end of high pinto sale numbers. It is a perfect example of white collar crime where profit is prioritized over ethical concerns. The ford pinto scandal is now part of the lore of american culture. The lawsuits brought by injured people and their survivors uncovered how the company rushed the pinto through production and onto the market. Read this free business coursework and other term papers, research papers and book reports.
The ford pinto case and the development of auto safety regulations, 18931978 article pdf available january 1998 with 2,620 reads how we measure reads. This paper recounts the ford pinto case, describes various ethical. The ford pinto case is today considered a classic example of corporate wrongdoing and is a mainstay of courses in engineering ethics, business ethics, philosophy, and the sociology of white collar crime. Driving a 1973 ford pinto to their church volleyball practice in goshen, indiana, they were struck from behind by a chevrolet van. An ethical analysis of the ford pinto case, a perfect example of white collar crime where profit is prioritized over ethical concerns.
Ford knows the pinto is a firetrap, yet it has paid out millions to settle damage suits out of court, and it is prepared to spend millions more lobbying against safety standards. The paper first presents an insider account of the context and decision environment within which he failed to initiate an early recall of defective vehicles. On august 10, 1978, a tragic automobile accident occurred on u. To monetize human life for the purpose of a costbenefits. Ford decided, however, not to change the position of the gas tank primarily in order to reduce production costs. Revisiting the ford pinto case fhsu scholars repository. As a thorough study, this book provides material that enriches the entire idea of. Ethical theories applicable to ford pinto case philosophy. The ford pinto and the dominant view this car became legendary, though perhaps infamous is a better word for the pintos reputation. This paper recounts the ford pinto case, describes various ethical decision. This article details the personal involvement of the author in the early stages of the infamous pinto fire case. The conventional account of the case goes something like this.
Pdf the ford pinto case and the development of auto. Ford pinto ethics when it comes to ethics, safety and car companies, more recent events like the protracted toyota or general motors recall issues or the fordfirestone fiasco probably come pages. Founder henry ford converted an old wagon factory to house his new inventions. Kramer the ford pinto ethical dilemma in this presentation, a very important case that transpired from 1971 to 1978 with the ford motor company, under the. Price organizational ethics and social responsibility 16 aug 2010 paul a. The ford pinto case is mentioned in most business ethics texts as an example of costbenefit analysis, yet in those formats any appreciation of the complexity surrounding the issues of such decisions is overly simplified. In the pinto case, fords decisionmaking framework is a great example of why it is not a good business strategy to employ an egoist whom recklessly views consumers as a means to their selfish ends. Provides an accounting of the ford motor company handling a product security controversy 19701977 his surroundings pinto subcompact. The ethical dilemma in the ford pinto case essay 1610. This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on monday, january 23, 2017. The ford pinto has been cited and debated in numerous business ethics as well as tort reform case studies. Ford motor company manages ethics and social responsibility introduction ford motor company, one of the big three automakers, was established in detroit, michigan, on june 16, 1903.
Act utilitarianism applied to the ford pinto release. Michael hoffman, was included in the first edition of business ethics, ed. However, the company refused to implement it, although it can prevent 180 deaths from. A cognitive script analysis of the personal experience is then offered as an explanation of factors that led to a decision. Ford and the auto industry in general convinced nhtsa regulators that a costbenefit analysis would be an. Mounted in this position, the tank was punctured during tests by projecting bolts when hit from the rear at 20 niph. The evidence suggests that ford relied, at least in part, on costbenefit reasoning, which is an analysis in monetary terms of the. The normal time to produce an automobile is 43 months ford took 25 for the pinto. During the development of the pinto, ford and other automakers faced increased safety requirements for the federal government and consumer groups. In an effort to produce a stylish but affordable subcompact automobile with a low operating cost, ford motor company management made a questionable decision regarding the positioning of and protection for the fuel tank. A paper i wrote for my business ethics class, not particularly a particularly creative or exciting assignment but i wanted to show some of my more formal writing. The case of the ford pinto in the early 1970s when competition from japans auto makers was heating up, gas prics were easing, the demands for energy conservation were just around the corner awaiting the arab oil boycotts that arrived first in 197374, ford motor company with lee iacocca as its president, introduced a new line of cars, the. The invisible corporate human pricetag in this essay, i will argue that ford motor companys business behavior was unethical as demonstrated in the ford pinto case. The ford pinto ethical dilemma written by learning team b.
Ford had the design to reduce the possibility of ford pinto from exploding. Ford followed the federal safety standards as they where current written. Although the pinto passed the nhtsa test, ford officials knew that the. Pdf case study ford pinto case jose calel academia. The main controversy surrounding the ford pinto case was the ford motor companys choices made during development to compromise safety for efficiency and profit maximization. There was a time when the made in japan label brought a predictable smirk of superiority to the face of most americans. The pinto case brought up issue of abusing human rights and behaved unethically in business. Ford motor company manages ethics and social responsibility.
The quality of most japanese products usually was as low as their price. As a thorough study, this book provides material that enriches the entire. The ford pinto is a subcompact car produced by the ford motor company for the model years 19711980. Abstract, in designing its 1971 pinto, the ford motor company. In nearly all rearend crash test collisions the pintos fuel system would rupture extremely easily. The cases involving the explosion of ford pintos due to a defective fuel. The ford motor company has faced a good deal of criticism for their choices in that case.
Between 1971 and 1978, approximately fifty lawsuits were brought against ford in connection with rearend accidents in the pinto. Initially offered as a twodoor sedan, ford offered runabout hatchback and wagon models the following year, competing in the u. Ethics is a general term which involves the aspects of rights and wrongs which determines the way in which humans live together in harmony in any given society. The ethical dilemma in the ford pinto case essay 1604 words. In designing its 1971 pinto, the ford motor company. Before production, ford engineers discovered flaws in the cars design. Fords decision was based on the results of a costbenefit analysis contained in the notorious pinto memo, written by ford engineers to guide design decisions. Ford did not reveal all the facts to consumers about a. The pinto was a subcompact car manufactured by the ford motor company for the model years 19711980. The placement of the cars fuel tank was the result of both conservative industry practice of the time as well the uncertain regulatory environment during the development and early sales periods of. Gioia on august 10, 1978, three teenage girls died horribly in an automobile accident. Sisters judy and lynn ulrich ages 18 and 16, respectively and their cousin donna ulrich age 18 were struck from. More specifically, it was fords decision to use the costbenefit analysis detailed in section 11 to make production decisions that translated into lost lives. Ford pinto the case over here is that of pinto a car launched by ford motor company.
963 877 731 1384 133 1426 1008 1183 974 631 417 959 877 463 413 95 1343 1089 734 1185 703 493 1354 896 1239 993 1010 1100 1163 1270 636 1417 346 435 1080 1074 145 776 441 1374 958